Imaginary Syllabi: BBQ Science
[imaginary-syllabi
science
gpt5
]
Premise: A semester-long course on the science and history of barbecue…
Learning Goals
By the end of the course, students will be able to:
- Relate muscle structure and composition—including collagen, myoglobin, fat, and water—to the expected cooking behavior and eating quality of specific meat cuts.
- Explain and quantify the combustion and pyrolysis processes that produce heat and smoke, including the relationship between fuel, oxygen availability, smoke composition, and PAH exposure.
- Analyze the chemical and physical transformations occurring during barbecue cooking, including protein denaturation, collagen solubilization, fat rendering, evaporation, smoke deposition, and Maillard browning.
- Construct and evaluate a heat- and mass-transfer model for a barbecue cook, using temperature and mass data to account for conduction, convection, radiation, evaporation, geometry, and the stall.
- Collect, calibrate, and interpret experimental data from meat, fuel, smoke, and temperature-control experiments; communicate uncertainty and apply appropriate food and laboratory safety practices.
- Situate American barbecue within its historical and cultural contexts.
Pre-reqs
- Gen Chem II, Calc II.
Reading List
- Goldwyn & Blonder, Meathead: The Science of Great Barbecue and Grilling (2016) – primary resource
- McGee, On Food and Cooking: The Science and Lore of the Kitchen — classic text on science and cooking; relevance here is Chpt 3 on meat.
- Moss, Barbecue: The History of an American Institution (2nd ed, 2025) –A carefully researched history tracing barbecue from Indigenous pit cooking through colonial America into modern regional traditions.
- (reference material on reserve) Myhrvold et al Modernist Cuisine (2011). – far too exp(a/e)nsive as a required purchase text, but lots of detail on heat transport, meat science, etc.
- (reference) Lawrie’s Meat Science, 9th ed — classic reference for meat professionals
- (reference) Meat Evaluation Handbook
Labs
Safety considerations: Food safety (raw-meat handling), combustion gases, and carcinogenic smoke compounds.
- Meat quality determination (visual inspection, microscopy)
- Bomb calorimetry of hardwoods & comparison calculations to propane.
- Smoke analysis via HPLC determination of polyaromatic hydrocarbons or GC-MS or FTIR, or analytical pyrolysis
- Properties of ionic solutions: osmotic pressure, diffusion, ionic strength (for relevance to brining)
- Differential scanning calorimetry of collagen denaturation and gelatin gelation
- Maillard reactions of amino acids and sugars
- PID controllers — thermocouple calibration, sensor placement, logging uncertainty, and controller tuning.
- Instrumented slow-cooker/smoker with feedback control
- Heat transfer modeling – computational lab
Example Capstone Projects
- Predicting the stall: Develop a heat- and mass-transfer model for pork shoulder or brisket; compare predictions against logged smoker data and explain discrepancies.
- Fuel, smoke, and flavor: Compare two hardwoods or charcoal versus hardwood under controlled conditions. Measure temperature profiles, mass loss, and smoke/PAH proxy data; recommend a fuel strategy with safety tradeoffs.
- Designing a stable smoker: Build or prototype a PID-controlled slow-cooker/smoker system. Calibrate sensors, tune the controller, quantify temperature stability, and document uncertainty.
- The science of a regional barbecue: Select a regional tradition and connect its preferred animal, cut, fuel, cooking method, and sauce to meat science, heat transfer, and its cultural history.
- Brining as transport science: Test salt concentration, time, and cut thickness; model diffusion and evaluate effects on mass change, water retention, texture, and sensory results.
- Collagen, temperature, and tenderness: Compare low-and-slow cooking schedules for a collagen-rich cut. Use temperature logging and texture/structure observations to identify an evidence-based endpoint.
- Smoke deposition and surface chemistry: Investigate how humidity, surface dryness, temperature, or smoke exposure affects bark formation and smoke deposition, while explicitly addressing PAH risk and experimental limitations.
- A reproducible barbecue protocol: Create a scientifically justified, reproducible cook protocol for a chosen cut, including ingredient and fuel specifications, sensor placement, control strategy, predicted outcomes, safety plan, and historical context.
Other resources
Fordham implementation notes
Place in the new core curriculum: Scientific Inquiry, Quantitative Inquiry (esp. if we build up the modeling aspects), Senior Capstone.
Fordham has history courses including Food and Drink in Modern Society, Food Politics, and Seminar: Food and Drink in Modern History on the books. Possible co-conspirators (perhaps enabling a History Inquiry designation?):
| Name | Focus snapshot |
|---|---|
| Thomas Hertweck | English / American Studies; food studies, vegan studies, ecocriticism, food packaging, film, and American literature and culture. |
| Julie Chun Kim | English; food studies, Afro-Caribbean medicine and food, Indigenous land rights, colonialism, empire, and science. |
| Thierry Rigogne | History; early modern food history and the history of cafés; teaches “The Social Life of Coffee” and “Food and Drink in Modern Society.” |
GenAI use
gpt-5.6-terra-mediumused in codex to generate learning goals and possible capstone projects from draft notes and research current course offerings in history and possible collaborators